What Vauxhall's Factory Closure Means for the EV Sector
The worldwide shift towards electric vehicles is sparking intense discussions between industry experts, governments and the public over the economic and operational hurdles that come with transformative, industry-wide changes.
With change comes some degree of instability, and Vauxhall is the latest vehicle manufacturer to feel the ground moving beneath its feet, announcing the closure of its production facility in Luton, UK.
The brass tacks: this closure could lead to around 1,100 job losses.
This situation speaks to the tension between aggressive regulatory goals guiding the sustainable transition of the transport sector and the actual conditions in the market.
It is also fuelling demands for policies that can better accommodate the evolving landscape so closures like this can be avoided in the future.
Why is the Vauxhall factory closing?
Vauxhall, one of the UK's oldest vehicle manufacturers, is struggling to cope with big shifts in market conditions.
Stellantis, the company that runs Vauxhall's factory in Luton, blames the UK’s stagnant economy and Westminster's zero-emissions vehicle (ZEV) mandate.
Brexit is also a strong factor in the downturn of Vauxhall's fortunes, with Stellantis saying that further closures may follow if further tariffs on UK-EU trade are imposed.
However, the main problem is the impending phase-out of internal combustion engine vehicles (ICEVs), which are fuelled by petrol or diesel.
As the ban on purchasing new ICEVs approaches, currently 2035 in the UK, it appears as though consumers are less willing to buy new, further exemplified by Ford's recent lay-offs in Europe.
The reaction of the industry
Industry leaders have raised concerns about the strict targets set for EV production and the effect of these goals on the automotive sector. Oliver Zipse, CEO of BMW, has openly criticised the EU's approach to EV mandates and tariffs, calling them "overly prescriptive regulations" and advocating for a more varied strategy towards sustainability.
These sentiments are shared by Italian Prime Minister Georgia Maloni and officials in the Czech Republic, a significant automotive hub, who argue that flexible regulations are vital to protect their manufacturing industries.
What's more, Guillaume Cartier, Chairperson for Nissan's AMIEO region, has warned against the UK's ZEV mandate, saying it "risks undermining the business case for manufacturing cars in the UK and the viability of thousands of jobs and billions of pounds in investment".
Additionally, Carlos Tavares, CEO of Stellantis, expressed concerns over the financial implications of investing simultaneously in EVs and ICEVs.
"When you make a longer transition, in fact, you don’t replace the old world with a new one. You add up the new world to the old," he explained.
What are the barriers to widespread EV adoption?
Financial Constraints
The adoption of EVs among consumers is lagging behind expectations, hampered by various economic pressures including post-pandemic recovery, ongoing global conflicts and increased taxation.
Despite a general willingness to shift to electric alternatives for future vehicle purchases, the initial high costs associated with EVs paired with the reduction in government incentives are proving to be significant deterrents.
Greg Bollefer, EVP of Commercial & Product Development at Green Worldwide Shipping, says: "While people are open to going electric for future purchases, they resist pressure to abandon their existing cars too soon."
Consumer Sentiment
Many drivers are becoming increasingly irritated by policies that penalise petrol car ownership, especially those who believe their current vehicles can remain functional for many more years.
"The sentiment is clear: consumers are willing to evolve but prefer a gradual, organic shift rather than immediate penalties on their current choices," says Greg.
The gathering storm for vehicle manufacturers
It's an understatement to say that manufacturers find themselves in a tough spot. It feels like spinning plates: trying to balance advancing EV technologies and ongoing ICEV production.
This dual approach strains resources and adds layers of complexity to long-term strategic planning. Despite considerable advancements, the industry is still grappling with aligning its processes to meet the ambitious sustainability targets set by regulators.
As Mike Hawes, CEO of the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, says: “We need an urgent review of the automotive market and the regulation intended to drive it. Not because we want to water down any commitments, but because delivery matters more than notional targets.
"The industry is hurting; profitability and viability are in jeopardy and jobs are on the line. When the world changes, so must we.”
Explore the latest edition of Sustainability Magazine and be part of the conversation at our global conference series, Sustainability LIVE.
Discover all our upcoming events and secure your tickets today.
Sustainability Magazine is a BizClik brand
