The Sustainability Impacts of the UK's Disposable Vape Ban

The UK Government has recently announced its commitment to ban disposable vapes by June 2025.

This significant move targets the dual objectives of environmental protection and curbing the rising trend of vaping among the youth.

Disposable vapes have soared in popularity among teenagers, posing a pressing concern as a colossal five million disposable vapes are discarded each week across the UK alone.

As well as the issue of waste, the decision is a response to the alarming rate at which young people are adopting vaping habits.

However, the vaping industry warns that this ban could inadvertently boost the black market.

Without effective controls on imports, illegal sales might flourish, complicating regulatory and enforcement efforts.

ELFBAR, a major vape manufacturer globally, has expressed support for the government’s intent but voiced disappointment over the comprehensive ban.

An ELFBAR spokesperson said: "We support efforts to address underage vaping and environmental concerns, and understand the motivation for the English and Welsh Governments to move forward with the decision, which the rest of the UK is expected to align on.

"Our concern is the potential impact on the majority of single-use vapers – adult smokers using them as a less harmful alternative, pushing them to the black market and illicit products."

The environmental impact of vape manufacturing

Health Minister Andrew Gwynne voiced his concerns, stating: "It’s deeply worrying that a quarter of 11 to 15-year-olds used a vape last year.

"Banning disposable vapes will not only protect the environment but importantly reduce the appeal of vapes to children."

Retail outlets have until 1 June, 2025 to clear their existing stocks.

The production of e-cigarettes, especially disposable types, depends on a complex supply chain encompassing a variety of raw materials and components.

Unlike traditional cigarettes, these require conflict minerals like tungsten, tin, tantalum and gold for their microprocessors.

Central to their functioning are lithium-ion batteries, which call for lithium, copper and bauxite — materials also critical for other industries such as electric vehicles and renewable energy solutions.

The extraction of these minerals, particularly lithium in the Andean region of South America, involves significant environmental degradation, mainly water consumption in areas already facing scarcity, impacting local communities adversely.

This issue worsens with the growing production of disposable e-cigarettes, most of which end up as electronic waste.

The copper used in these products also raises major environmental concerns due to its mining processes, which can contaminate water supplies with heavy metals and chemicals, posing risks to both ecosystems and human health.

Thus, the UK's initiative to phase out these products is a step towards mitigating broader environmental impacts.

Advancing recycling initiatives

One of the critical challenges with disposable vapes is their recycling complexities.

These devices include lithium batteries — known for fire hazards if damaged — and e-liquids that can be toxic.

Currently, the UK lacks a comprehensive recycling programme for these products, leading to haphazard disposal methods.

Different battery types used across various models further complicate these processes.

Experts like Stuart Hayward-Higham, Chief Technical Development & Innovation Officer at SUEZ UK, have highlighted the risks associated with improper disposal, pointing out the dangers of compromised lithium batteries which can ignite spontaneously during transit.
“If a lithium battery is compromised in transit and is pierced, it may spontaneously ignite like a firework,” he says.

With potential small-scale lithium-ion battery recycling plants expected by 2024, there's a push towards building a robust recycling infrastructure in the UK.

The regulatory framework is also shifting, with discussions around Extended Producer Responsibility regulations aimed at making producers more accountable for the end-of-life phase of their products.

These changes could foster more sustainable practices within the vaping industry.

Transitioning to reusable vape systems

The discussion around disposable vapes also includes the emerging trend towards reusable vaping devices.

A survey by Vape Superstore showed that while 66% of respondents primarily used disposable vapes, many are open to switching to reusable systems if disposable ones were banned.

The government’s 'Swap to Stop' programme further supports this transition by offering free refillable vape kits to adult smokers in England, promoting more sustainable consumer behaviour.

Manufacturers are beginning to develop biodegradable components for vapes and introducing recycling schemes for their products.

These developments could help alleviate some environmental and public health issues caused by the ban on disposables.

However, the industry remains vigilant about the possible rise of a black market if enforcement of the new regulations is not stringent enough.

The UK Vaping Industry Association suggests stronger penalties for retailers who sell to minors and more strict retail licensing to tackle this issue effectively.

These measures, combined with efforts to make vaping less appealing to children through packaging regulations, could contribute to controlling youth vaping without resorting to a total ban.

As the vaping market expands, striking a balance between public health concerns, environmental sustainability and economic implications continues to be a challenge.

However, the UK's proactive measures towards sustainable practices represent a positive step forward in managing these complexities.

Make sure you check out the latest edition of Sustainability Magazine and also sign up to our global conference series - Sustainability LIVE 2024

Sustainability Magazine is a BizClik brand