Q&A: Why is the British Heat Pump Revolution Faltering?

Share
Successful installation of heat pumps requires years of experience with traditional heating and plumbing systems.
Graham Rothwell, CEO of RPS on engineering bottlenecks, government support & why making heat pumps economically viable is essential to achieving net zero

Good news! We've found the solution to all our (heating) problems.

According to the World Economic Forum, heating buildings with fossil fuel boilers accounts for 40% of global CO₂ emissions, but fear not, we already have a great alternative. Heat pumps.

Heat pumps are the much lauded electric alternative to traditional boiler systems. But what makes them so special?

  1. Heat pumps can be three to four times as efficient as gas boilers, meaning they can produce more heat from less input
  2. Speaking of fuel, heat pumps do not burn anything to create warmth, meaning they produce no local emissions. Instead, they use electricity from the grid to suck in the air around them, converting it to heat
  3. What's more, they can be far less expensive to run than boilers, given the right market conditions.
Youtube Placeholder

It all sounds so simple, right? Well, there are a couple of hitches, especially in the UK.

We spoke to Graham Rothwell, CEO of Rothwells Plumbing Services, to get the inside track on why engineers are finding it hard to deliver the rollout of heat pumps in the UK.

Graham Rothwell, CEO of Rothwells Plumbing Services

How can the UK Government help heating contractors meet net zero goals?

We need more certainty on the retrofit agenda, specifically regarding funding schemes and implementation timelines. We require clarity on financial support availability and rollout timelines, often via social landlords. 

This includes grants and subsidies to make upgrades affordable for businesses and homeowners.

With this clarity, we can confidently invest in recruiting, training, and upskilling staff. The transition to low-carbon technologies like air source heat pumps demands a workforce trained in installation, maintenance and advisory roles.

Without clear government backing, investing in upskilling is risky as future demand for these skills is uncertain. 

Strong commitment and a well-defined framework from the government will enable businesses to boost recruitment and create green jobs.

The UK Government will have a key role to play in the uptake of heat pumps

Is there a shortage of expertise in retrofitting low-carbon heating systems?

Yes. Successful installation requires years of experience with traditional heating and plumbing systems, which vary significantly between properties. 

Air source heat pumps, for example, demand both electrical and plumbing know-how, making specialised training essential.

The technology is constantly evolving, requiring ongoing skill development for installation and maintenance. 

Continuous training and hands-on experience are critical; it's not a one-off learning curve but an ongoing investment. Without proper resources and commitment, we can't meet growing demand or deliver these systems effectively.

Many British engineers and plumbers are still unfamiliar with heat pump technology

Is there more that can be done on training?

We need to invest in the next generation of workers, but hiring apprentices comes with commercial challenges.

New, inexperienced people require extra staff and resources for training, which is especially challenging for SMEs

Seasoned installers, paid on project completion, may be reluctant to take on apprentices as it can slow them down.

I believe companies should not bear the full weight of funding apprenticeships. The central government should play a larger role in financing training and employment. 

The business landscape has changed significantly, with shorter contracts and less stability, making it harder to justify training investments.

Could more be done on education around air source heat pumps?

Absolutely. The messaging in the media has been too negative and it's time for a shift.

Government needs to promote this technology more positively. We face confusion and distrust from people who don't understand the technology, leading to installation pushback. 

Early engagement is key, but it requires time to explain the long-term impact.

We need earlier education on why heat pumps and low-energy tech are the future. An education programme highlighting renewable energy benefits could shape public opinion and drive demand for heat pumps.

It is a common misconception that heat pumps do not function at cold temperatures; Scandinavian homes are often fitted with heat pumps. This works because the buildings are well insulated against heat loss

What other areas can heat contractors be better supported?

One of our biggest hurdles is lack of support from Distribution Network Operators (DNOs).

Installing heat pumps requires coordination with local electricity providers due to increased infrastructure demands. DNO delays can kill momentum, often causing tenants to change their minds. 

Greater government awareness and pressure could speed up installations and help us hit targets.

We want a national plan for net-zero retrofits and fast-tracked agreements between DNOs and social landlords. Solving this issue is crucial for meeting the country's net zero targets and benefiting everyone involved.

******

Make sure you check out the latest edition of Sustainability Magazine and also sign up to our global conference series - Sustainability LIVE 2024

******

Sustainability Magazine is a BizClik brand

******

Share

Featured Articles

How Workiva is Transforming ESG Reporting Strategies

Corporate reporting platform Workiva's latest study reveals 97% of executives see sustainability data integration as key to business growth by 2026

This Week's Top Five Stories in Sustainability

This week's top stories include a forecast for DEI across 2025, missed UN NDC deadlines, energy revolution in the Baltics, Starbucks' legal case & AI laws

McKinsey Will ‘Boldy Pursue’ DEI in Face of Storm

Reports say McKinsey has doubled down on DEI initiatives despite other high-profile firms and businesses retreating from pledges after US executive orders

Apple, IBM & GM Amongst Those Set For DEI Showdowns in 2025

Diversity & Inclusion (D&I)

Which 10 Nations Met the UN's Deadline for NDC Targets?

Net Zero

What Next as Baltic States Switch off Russian Energy Supply?

Renewable Energy