Starbucks Sued by Missouri Over ‘Unlawful’ DEI Policies
Coffee shop giant Starbucks is the latest major US-headquartered company to face a legal challenge to its diversity, equity and inclusion policies.
The coffee chain is being sued by the US state of Missouri, which has accused it of tying executive pay to its aim to achieve racial and gender-based hiring quotas.
The complaint from Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey says “all of this is unlawful”.
Starbucks defended its policies, saying Missouri’s allegations are “inaccurate”.
Starbucks stands accused
The lawsuit, filed in St Louis federal court on Tuesday, accuses Starbucks of using a commitment to DEI as a front to systematically discriminate based on race, gender and sexual orientation.
Missouri said the firm ties executive pay to achieving racial and gender-based hiring quotas.
It also accused Starbucks of singling out preferred groups for additional training and job advancement prospects.
On top of this, it said the coffee chain employs a quota system to ensure its own board of directors has a variety of racial and ethnic backgrounds.
“All of this is unlawful” and violates federal and state civil rights laws, Bailey said.
Bailey added the claim that Missouri consumers pay higher prices and wait longer for services at Starbucks than if the Seattle-based chain employed the most qualified workers.
Starbucks said in a statement: “We disagree with the attorney general and these allegations are inaccurate.
“We are deeply committed to creating opportunity for every single one of our partners [employees]. Our programmes and benefits are open to everyone and lawful.”
A business battleground
DEI has been front and centre of the global news agenda since the inauguration of US President Donald Trump in January.
President Trump has made it clear that he believes DEI policies and programmes are discriminatory and has signed a series of Executive Orders to roll them back.
The moves have changed the atmosphere in boardrooms at many of the globe’s largest companies.
Some companies have ended or curtailed their own DEI policies, including Google, which scrapped diversity-based hiring targets.
The Wall Street bank Goldman Sachs on Tuesday cancelled a policy to take companies public only if they had two diverse board members, while Amazon.com removed a reference to inclusion and diversity from its annual report.
Starbucks: not the only target
Earlier this week, a lawsuit was filed against Target over its ESG and DEI initiatives after the company reined back its Belonging at the Bullseye programme.
The US retail giant has been sued for allegedly concealing the risks of its social and diversity initiatives.
The lawsuit claims the company defrauded shareholders into paying inflated prices for its stock and unknowingly supporting management's "misuse of investor funds to serve political and social goals”.
This year, Target has also said it would end DEI initiatives in 2025.
More to come?
The coming year is likely to be critical in the fight to establish how DEI will look in the future.
Apple, Coca-Cola, IBM, GM, Levi's and Berkshire Hathaway are among firms facing shareholder scrutiny over diversity policies this year.
DEI policies were a frequent point of discussion for President Trump during his election campaign and his focus on them has not slipped since he took office in January 2025.
In the US, diversity, equity and inclusion are organisational frameworks that seek to promote the fair treatment and full participation of all people, particularly groups who have historically been underrepresented or subject to discrimination based on identity or disability.
President Trump has described this approach as “dangerous, demeaning and immoral” and has often called the policies “nonsense”.
Many companies have followed Trump’s lead since his election, though many remain committed to DEI.
Explore the latest edition of Sustainability Magazine and be part of the conversation at our global conference series, Sustainability LIVE.
Discover all our upcoming events and secure your tickets today.
Sustainability Magazine is a BizClik brand
